Find your next fishing spot near Shelter Island Heights, New York
There are 12 lakes to explore within 13 miles of Shelter Island Heights.
Check out the best fishing spots in Shelter Island Heights, New York. Use Lake-Link to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots. Become a Pro subscriber to find out the best times and how to catch your favorite fish.
Hashamomuck Pond
Approx 3.3 miles away
- SIZE: 133 acres
Great Pond
Approx 5.8 miles away
- SIZE: 30 acres
Long Pond
Approx 7.3 miles away
- SIZE: 58 acres
Wooley Pond
Approx 8.8 miles away
- SIZE: 32 acres
Poxabogue Pond
Approx 9.5 miles away
- SIZE: 44 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 4 ft
Scallop Pond
Approx 10.4 miles away
- SIZE: 128 acres
Watermill Pond
Approx 11.1 miles away
- SIZE: 120 acres
Mill Pond
Approx 11.1 miles away
- SIZE: 97 acres
Georgica Pond
Approx 11.1 miles away
- SIZE: 291 acres
Wainscott Pond
Approx 11.4 miles away
- SIZE: 35 acres
Sagaponack Pond
Approx 11.7 miles away
- SIZE: 92 acres
Hook Pond
Approx 11.8 miles away
- SIZE: 64 acres
