HOME
LAKES
REPORTS
FORUMS
TRAVEL
DEALS
SEARCH
MORE
Wisconsin Fishing Discussion

Please help....ban fishing guides from gifting their catch to their clients..........

1/28/20 @ 11:25 AM
INITIAL POST
Fin Bender
Fin Bender
User since 9/16/11

Guides in Wisconsin fish nearly every day. They have the ability to catch many, many fish; and they do. This is not a concern in itself. What is a great concern is the legal practice of guides who gift their catch to clients.

For those who don't know about this here is how it works: a client hires a guide to take him fishing. On most bodies of water without special regulations that client can catch 3 walleye in one day, so far so good. The guide can also catch his 3 walleye. Six total walleye in the boat. Here is where it gets ugly. That guide can drive back to landing and "gift" his catch to the client. The client then goes home with six fish, even though his daily limit is 3. To top it off, they can drive to another lake and repeat this same practice for 4 more walleye (2 each) and send the client home with 10 walleye.

As you can see this practice is of concern. It's nearly impossible to enforce, meaning it's very easy for the guide to simply allow his client to catch all the fish, which is not legal. Also because of how often guides fish there is a concern that this is an abuse of the resource. If the guide was simply fishing for himself he would not be able to keep that many fish day after day because he would exceed his possession limit. This practice allows the keeping of many more fish than what was intended by current law.

What I don’t know is how this loop-hole in the law can be closed. Walleye in Wisconsin are on the decline and this is adding to the problem. How can this be stopped?

Displaying 76 to 89 of 89 posts
1/28/20 @ 3:13 PM
Hunter&Hound
User since 7/24/01

It's very common in Vilas County and evident by their posts.


Having said that, I think the walleye fishing is excellent and I choose not to get my tit in a wringer over it.

1/28/20 @ 3:03 PM
Greenheads4Ever
Greenheads4Ever
PRO MEMBER User since 2/9/03

In the last 4-5 years I have hired two Lake Michigan charter boats, 2 fully guided whitefish trips on Sturgeon Bay and 4 semi guided, a guided trip on Bago and a guided trip on Geneva.  I do these mostly to learn techniques or strategies on large bodies of water that I may not be familiar with.  In all of these trips I have never had a guide or charter let me or my group catch their bag or gift us their fish.  I know this is a small subset, but having many guide friends myself, I think this is blown way out of proportion and does not happen as often as believed.  In my experience, guides are better stewards of the resource than most other fisherman. 

1/28/20 @ 1:40 PM
Fin Bender
Fin Bender
User since 9/16/11

I'm not sure why you say that. I read the terms of agreement and I don't think I made any violations. In fact when this came up last year in the fishing reports the moderators removed those posts and specifically said that topic belongs here in the forums section.

Anyway, I hope you support the closing of this loop-hole and I'm looking for ideas on how to change the law that allows this. Is this allowed by DNR code or state statute? I'm not in the political or legal arena so this is kind of foreign to me.

1/28/20 @ 1:33 PM
Hunter&Hound
User since 7/24/01

This isn't going to last long....

Displaying 76 to 89 of 89 posts
Copyright © 2001-2024 Lake-Link Inc. All rights reserved.
No portion of this website can be used or distributed without prior written consent of Lake-Link, Inc.
This website may contain affiliate links, meaning when you click the links and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission.
Lake-Link Home
fish seduced by
MENU
MORE TO EXPLORE