Eaton Reservoir
Madison County, New York
Today's Fishing Forecast
Fishing looks to be moderately active with peak fishing times around 2-4 PM. SEE MORE

Eaton Brook Reservoir is fairly steep sided, with deep water often only a short distance from shore in some areas. This, coupled with the very clear water, can often make fishing challenging. Most anglers target the rainbow trout shortly after they're stocked in the spring but some hold-over fish are taken most winters by anglers ice fishing the reservoir. Walleye can often be difficult to catch, but when a lucky angler gets one, it's usually a nice sized one in the 20+ inch range. Largemouth bass are more abundant than smallmouth with fish in the 13 to 15 inch range common for both species. Chain pickerel are abundant, though most hover around the legal length of 15 inches.
Share your catch!
We want to see what you've caught on Eaton Reservoir.Frequently Asked Questions About Eaton Reservoir, NY
- How big is Eaton Reservoir?
- How deep is Eaton Reservoir?
- What kind of fish can you catch in Eaton Reservoir?
- What are the closest cities to Eaton Reservoir?
- Are there places to stay in the Eaton Reservoir area?
- Are there boat launches on Eaton Reservoir?
- Are there places to eat and drink near Eaton Reservoir?
- What is the average air temp for Eaton Reservoir?
- Are there any state parks near Eaton Reservoir?
How big is Eaton Reservoir?
How deep is Eaton Reservoir?
What kind of fish can you catch in Eaton Reservoir?
Other fish species in the lake include Chain Pickerel, Golden Shiner and White Sucker.
What are the closest cities to Eaton Reservoir?
Are there places to stay in the Eaton Reservoir area?
More Lodging Options
Are there boat launches on Eaton Reservoir?
Are there places to eat and drink near Eaton Reservoir?
Explore the Eaton Reservoir area in a RV
Are you looking for an adventurous vacation option that won't break the bank? Look no further than renting an RV! Contrary to popular belief, the process is much simpler than you might imagine. With just a few easy steps, you'll soon be experiencing the ultimate freedom and convenience of exploring the open road in your very own recreational vehicle. And the best part? RV travel can save you up to 60% compared to other types of vacations! With the money you'll save, you'll be able to travel even more and create unforgettable memories along the way. So why wait? Start planning your next adventure today with an RV rental. Learn more about renting a RV.
2018 Keystone Cougar X-Lite, Sleeps 10, delivery offered, Pet Friendly
Boonville, NY
History & Status of the Fishery
What is the average air temp for Eaton Reservoir?
Are there any state parks near Eaton Reservoir?
For more New York State Park information see our State Park Guide.
More Nearby Lakes To Explore
There's more lake's to explore around Eaton Reservoir...| DISTANCE | ACRES | MAX DEPTH | |
| Stoney Pond | 1.7 mi | 28 | 12 ft |
| Hatch Lake | 2.1 mi | 134 | |
| Bradley Brook Reservoir | 2.6 mi | 139 | |
| Torpy Pond | 2.7 mi | 42 | |
| Tuscarora Lake | 3.0 mi | 308 | 40 ft |
| Seymour Pond | 5.6 mi | 11 | |
| Leland Pond | 6.5 mi | 52 | |
| Woodman Pond | 6.7 mi | 94 | |
| Miller Lake | 7.3 mi | 100 | |
| Lake Moraine | 9.2 mi | 251 | 45 ft |



