Find your next fishing spot near Brewster, New York
There are 10 lakes to explore within 4 miles of Brewster.
Check out the best fishing spots in Brewster, New York. Use Lake-Link to view local fishing regulations, read reviews of local fishing spots. Become a Pro subscriber to find out the best times and how to catch your favorite fish.
Middle Branch Reservoir
Approx 1.5 miles away
- SIZE: 395 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 62 ft
- AVG DEPTH: 31 ft
Lake Tonetta
Approx 1.7 miles away
- SIZE: 72 acres
East Branch Reservoir
Approx 1.9 miles away
- SIZE: 525 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 62 ft
- AVG DEPTH: 32 ft
Bog Brook Reservoir
Approx 2.0 miles away
- SIZE: 404 acres
- AVG DEPTH: 33 ft
Peach Lake
Approx 3.0 miles away
- SIZE: 245 acres
Lake Gilead
Approx 3.1 miles away
- SIZE: 118 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 120 ft
- AVG DEPTH: 43 ft
Croton Falls Reservoir
Approx 3.4 miles away
- SIZE: 1,062 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 108 ft
- AVG DEPTH: 41 ft
Haines Pond
Approx 3.5 miles away
- SIZE: 33 acres
Lake Gleneida
Approx 3.9 miles away
- SIZE: 168 acres
- MAX DEPTH: 108 ft
- AVG DEPTH: 48 ft
Ice Pond
Approx 4.0 miles away
- SIZE: 52 acres
