HOME
LAKES
REPORTS
FORUMS
DEALS
SEARCH
MORE
Wisconsin Hunting Reports/Discussion

DNR expecting more deer gun hunters each year always makes me laugh

Share this page:
11/30/22 @ 10:07 AM
INITIAL POST
Rattle em up
User since 4/19/21

Where does the DNR expect these people to hunt and have a reasonable expectation of harvesting deer? Mostly mature bucks. Unless you have private land access most groups in the north are not being that successful (I know there are some). Most are gone after opening weekend. 

A lot of hunters have moved south and find crowded public land areas and get disgruntled. Others are trying to shoot deer out of their backyards and are always confused when the neighboring farmers/hunters won't let them go retrieve their bambi when it runs off their two acre back yard.

Here is a thought DNR, quit giving out all those doe tags and try and work with the Feds to manage wolves. Them are the only options because we cannot control mother nature. 

Displaying 1 to 15 of 169 posts
1/21/23 @ 9:53 PM
Steelhead88
User since 4/13/22

Master Piker — Not sure where you’re at but usually survival is priority for the whitetail this time of year , In the north woods they “yard” for cover & feed , in other areas of the state it’s common for deer to gather in the winter months where food is easy or plentiful , (picked corn field , grazing ) . Pressure is low  so bedding close to food source is  common .  I’m assuming a few months ago not this many were seen together , before & after corn was picked . 

1/21/23 @ 8:53 PM
Master_Piker
Master_Piker
User since 12/7/05

robertwhite,

Sadly, in 2022/2023 the 'bullets in the gun' will more than likely be the limiting factor! 

All joking aside, I did take a drive out to our land yesterday and my pasture was TORE UP from all the deer eating out there. Glad those guys that said I shot too many deer this fall were wrong (phew!)...I had 6 of them bedded in the cattle corral where I park and two more were watching me from the other side of the pasture while grazing. The neighbor to the west had 23 of them in his picked cornfield when I was leaving at 2:30PM.

1/16/23 @ 10:01 AM
robertwhite
User since 3/18/08

Old hunter,

No. No restrictions.

Only thing restricting anyone is the number of tags in their pocket, number of bullets in the gun (or arrows in the quiver), and days available to hunt.

1/16/23 @ 9:35 AM
cm1234
User since 8/3/12

LOL catch up madforlabs, scroll back a few pages, I STARTED this conversation.

1/16/23 @ 9:06 AM
oldhunter
User since 2/28/13

robertwhite,    I meant restrictions placed by the landowners.  

1/16/23 @ 9:05 AM
oldhunter
User since 2/28/13

"Yes I have read them, unfortunately some cdac's disregard the feedback."



X-2.  

1/16/23 @ 8:31 AM
robertwhite
User since 3/18/08

“So what kind of restrictive hunting is in the immediate area?”

None. Only restrictions are 2 free antlerless tags per license. No hunter is forced to do anything. Not sure I want Earn a Buck back though 

All members of my counties CDAC are hunters. Forestry rep, Ag rep, Transportation rep, Private Lands rep. Tourism rep. All are hunters with varying opinions on deer numbers and how to manage them. Some express similar opinions to those shared here. 

1/15/23 @ 9:26 PM
ere
User since 2/22/07

Yes I have read them, unfortunately some cdac's disregard the feedback.

1/15/23 @ 6:13 PM
kona77
User since 6/20/13

Fish, the DNR will just claim that they already do that through the CDAC's. Which is a croc. Thank you, Dr Deer. extreme sarcasm.

Ere-  Have you looked at the comments section from the CDAC meetings in your county?? I am sure there are some counties where there is an overwhelming response on an issue (overall deer numbers/harvest goals etc)  and I would hope this gives some weight to the decision making process.  I live in Washington Cty and I can tell you the responses are all over the board.  The first question on the CDAC is if the responder agrees/disagrees with the Mgmt/Harvest Goal levels.. Last year there were 41 "Agree" (61%) responses and 26- Disagree. One of my pet peeves is the Holiday Hunt and 34 people agreed with this extra season and 34 -disagreed . Of course the comments section has all kinds of Points of View on issues covered on threads here on LL.  Gun hunters want the bow season shortened.  Most folks wanted fewer "public land antlerless" tags given out but a few folks wanted more.. Don't get that sentiment when you can get 3-free ones with your tag??    

Have reviewed meetings goals/comments from other counties I hunt and I see some of the same things. I still think the CDAC concept is a good one with feedback from various stakeholders. Of course reality is a different thing and I get why folks have lost confidence in this process.

1/15/23 @ 2:10 PM
ere
User since 2/22/07

Fish, the DNR will just claim that they already do that through the CDAC's. Which is a croc. Thank you, Dr Deer. extreme sarcasm.

1/15/23 @ 11:21 AM
fishfillet
User since 1/8/13

Whoever makes the rules needs to take into consideration of hunter feedback. I don't really see that happening.  Lots of public land is crappy wasteland too.  Why not use some funds to improve upon some areas as well?

1/14/23 @ 8:57 AM
Princecraft54
User since 7/22/21

Yes they could do something, go back to units and they could divide these counties.

1/13/23 @ 5:39 PM
ere
User since 2/22/07

it must suck walking around day after day just being miserable, Amen mad4.

1/13/23 @ 4:49 PM
oldhunter
User since 2/28/13

" When I walk out my door and count 21 deer in my neighbors hayfield, there shouldn’t be opportunity (tags) to shoot some because someone on the other side of the county sees fewer or no deer? "



So what kind of restrictive hunting is in the immediate area?


  There is a hunting spot couple miles down the road from where I hunt, that is about 200 acres of prime habitat.  It has about 9 nine hunters during firearm season.  Three of the property owners have a no shooting does or small bucks rule. One property owner during both bow and gun season may shoot one or two does and only bigger bucks. Any given time approaching dusk you could easily see 60 to 80 deer in the fields.  

Several miles  away and around, you could sit for days without seeing any deer. 


Do you think the DNR can control that?


If deer have a safe environment, that is where they will congregate. 

1/13/23 @ 3:37 PM
LittleLuck
User since 2/16/17

According to MFL we are not allowed to voice our viewpoints that the majority of the hunters in this state share. Must not like  that Twitter is not sensoring people anymore   Or doesn't like when we criticize his DNR..

Displaying 1 to 15 of 169 posts

HUMMINBIRD - Humminbird Sonar Series
Humminbird Sonar Series
This is your introduction to the world of Humminbird. From a breakdown of our different models to high-level overviews. PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT: HUMMINBIRD - Humminbird Sonar Series

MINN KOTA - Minn Kota Ultrex
Minn Kota Ultrex
Minn Kota Ultra: Proven in the real world. Year after year. PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT: MINN KOTA - Minn Kota Ultrex

OKUMA FISHING TACKLE - Avenger ABF Reels
Avenger ABF Reels
Baitfeeder spinning reels lend tremendous function to anglers. Okuma's baitfeeder system allows anglers to disengage their spinning reel spool and allow their bait to run freely. PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT: OKUMA FISHING TACKLE - Avenger ABF Reels

Copyright © 2001-2023 Lake-Link Inc. All rights reserved.
No portion of this website can be used or distributed without prior written consent of Lake-Link, Inc.
This website may contain affiliate links, meaning when you click the links and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission.
Lake-Link Home
fishing geared up by
MENU
MORE TO EXPLORE