Any thoughts or recommendations? Based on what?
Thannks in advance.
I'm pretty sure the weight differences nowadays is very minimal. I’m looking for a new 40 hp for my duck boat and pretty sure the Yamaha and Honda are both around 215 lbs. I’ve owned 5 mercs and an Evinrude and the only things I’ve ever fixed is a water pump impeller and rectifier. I’m open to all brands but hear nothing but good things about Yamaha.
I had a carbureted 90hp Honda on my old boat, and still have a 50hp Honda on the pontoon. Both are solid motors and I would not hesitate. The Honda's tend to run a little heavier weight wise. I have Yamaha's on my fishing boat now and they have been solid.
If I ever had to buy new or repower it would be with a Yamaha, solid, with better dealer network, parts and support. If you have a Honda dealers close by it would probably be a wash. I would not thumb my nose at a Honda, but if given the choice I would take Yamaha.
Can't go wrong with a 60HP Honda.
good luck
Tohatsu is not made in China, they are made in Japan and are excellent motors. In fact they are the largest maker of outboards in the world (Just not well known in US). And yes they make the motors for Mercury under 30HP (at least the power head). If you don't believe me Google it.
With that said I have a 2016 20HP Tohatsu on my river boat, never had a problem in 5 years now.
2011 50HP Yamaha on lake boat since 2011, No problems either.
Hondas are a decent motor, no doubt. They are typically a bit heavier though, and as mentioned, have a fairly skinny dealer network.
Excellent motors though.
I’ve been an e-etc guy for 12 years, but my next motor will be a Yamaha. I have a 15 hp Yamaha on my small fishing boat, and a 50 hp Yamaha on my pontoon, both excellent motors.
E-Tec still running strong on my glass fish / ski.
I would not hesitate to get the 60 Honda. None of the motors in that range get much attention or updates. They've all gone to fuel injection so cold starting and warm up are not an issue. I've run all of them and the Honda is the best running of the bunch. The Mercs are made in China as a joint venture with Tohatsu and are not as refined as the others.
As far as service - Suzuki may have more dealers, but their corporate service and parts support is terrible. Yamaha is a good engine and has a good dealer and corporate service network. The Yamaha ran well - I didn't think it had the acceleration of the Honda.
You have a good Honda dealer at Racine Riverside.
I agree with most comments, yammy great, suzuki great, honda seems to not be very active, Merc's good but not on same level. The one thing not mentioned but may be important is Yamaha is I believe the most expensive - So consider Suzuki. I think price wise you'll be surprised at how much less than Yamaha and also a great engine. Everyone I know that has a suzuki loves it.
When I bought my boat 13 years ago I was strictly a Merc guy, for 35 years. The dealer talked me into a Yamaha 60 4-Stroke and I absolutely Love It! Super quiet, sips gas and I haven't had any issues with it. When I was fishing Southern WI every weekend I noticed that even the new Mercs just sound like they are hard and loud starting just as the old ones. It also seemed that I saw more breakdowns with Honda's on the back. As said below, the dealer network seams smaller with Honda as well. My next boat will have a Yamaha on the back.
You can't go wrong with a Honda. I don't own one, but know several that do. If you have a dealer near you, do it. Yamaha is also one you may want to look at . Suzuki is gaining market share with Etec done. Lot's of boats down south run Suzuki and Yamaha, continue do some more research elsewhere and i'm sure you'll find a answer that is right for you.
Pretty much what has been said, small dealer support and dont think Honda really puts alot of time and effort into advancing the tech on their outboards as the other manufacturers do. That being said, my old college roommate has a 60 hp Honda on the boat at his cabin. He has owned it awhile, and I've fished out of that boat with him a few times a season for many years. The motor has been trouble free aside from routine maintenance. IMO though I would go Yammy or Merc simply for dealer network.