"Why is this trend troubling? Stringed weapon northern forest buck harvest, with several weeks to go, is up almost 26% from last years total. I’d bet when it’s all said and done northern forest total buck harvest will be up 10-15% from last year. "
If I were honest, I personally don't see it as troubling because I want more bucks to live annually - selfish as I bowhunt. However, from a big picture it is incredibly troubling. As rifle season success rates continue to trend in a nosedive (from predation, killing too many does, and more being shot before rifle season even starts), it will accelerate the loss of rifle hunters as a whole. There are multiple thousands of "non-serious" hunters out there that will never go bowhunting or use a crossbow. They consist of people who go for the tradition, to see the crew on opening weekend, and generally hunt public land mostly. These are the people that are quitting, and will be the most impacted when less deer are available.
Why is this a problem? Losing hunters is a problem. Not only from protecting our 2nd amendment and hunting rights, but for other reasons as well. Losing hunters hamstrings management. Hunters are the only tool game managers have that they can control in wildlife management. Secondly is money. With a loss of license revenue it impacts all of us at a state level. Also, loss of ammo and firearm sales impacts the Pittman-Robertson Act funds as 11% taxes (I think that is what it is) on guns and ammo goes directly to states to fund wildlife programs. This fund has done numerous things for management including the latest buck recovery studies in WI. Don't forget the impact to the economies with the loss of migration of hunters to the northwoods (hotels, restaurants, bars, grocers, etc.).
For guys with private land or in areas where there are a lot of deer you won't see a problem. But for us who hunt the Northern Forest units you can already tell what is happening. People pay money to expect a good product. When the product sucks, you quit buying it. There is a lot of concern about this.