There are currently 25 reviews for Nagawicka Lake.
Was out on Saturday, Jan. 27 at the North end of the lake, southeast of the kettle, and eventually just inside the east 1/4 of the kettle, and had a solid day with a group of friends. Had a few two-foot, healthy Northern Pike, and one 30-incher. The bite was strong early and tailed-off in the afternoon.
- Ross Boettcher from Oconomowoc, WI
This site has inaccurate data on the # of launch spots for the nagawaukee park launch... Per the DNR site there are: No. of Vehicle and Trailer Stalls 21-25
- dave jones from delafield, WI
Opening day started out nice 69deg.at 500 am by 830 53deg. 7 northerns all on shiners biggest 38 in/3 bass biggest 21 in in kettle. One 19 in walleye no crappies.only kept the all swimming except walleye.
- Rt440 Rt440 from milwaukee, WI
great lake to fish the canals on the west side, huge largemouth, and northern. use nightcrawlers or leaches. ive been fishing nagawicka all my life, and not once have i left empty handed. the boat launch could be cheaper tho. its $7.50
- Kenden Bauer from Milwaukee
Alot of northern but so many are really tiny
- Steven Ozminkowski from menomonee falls, Wisconsin
Fishing this lake used to be better but there are still some nice fish
- Steve Ozminkowski from Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin
- Harry Layton from Sussex, Wisconsin
The water quality of this lake is fantastic. It is probebly one of the clearest in the area. It is an easy lake to fish as there are very defined weed lines. I beleive the fishing in this lake was very good a few years back. However, It has not been stocked in many years and it gets a great deal of fishing presure. You will catch fish but you will have trouble finding anything that resembles a trophy catch.
- Nathan Hobbs from Nashotah, Wisconsin
I moved here 5 years ago and the lake had a national rep for bass! I have seen some 14"-16" Largemouth and many small smallies. The other reviews go back to 2003-any other current fish ratings out there? I don't think that the DNR has stocked Nagawicka for several years.
- Thomas O'Malley from Delafield, Wisconsin
I had great success in the kettle last year catching big blue gills but this year the lake seems dead i don't know what's going on but the fishing was a lot better last year I always fish in the winter and i always fish in over 40 feet that's where we always mark fish and it used to be where we caught them
- Ted Schroeder from Milwaukee, Wisconsin
A fantastic lake. Depths up to 96 feet, both clear and cloudy water all times of the year. Distinct weed lines and a wide variety of fish.
- Mike Schnitzka from Delafield, Wisconsin
GREAT LAKE TO PRACTICE YOUR CASTING....NEED BATHROOMS PLEASE
- MARK D from FRANKLIN, Wisconsin
When they're biting ice fishing for crappies in the kettle is great-we've kept 40+ fish between 10.5 and 13" after dark-this was a few years ago. Usually in 35 to 40+ feet-can be suspended anywhere. Never tried fishing open water here-usually in Shawano or Vilas County or on Pewaukee occasionally.
- One More Cast from Up North, Wisconsin
What a graet lake!!! smallies, wallies , big gills. fish deep weeds with live bait. You cant miss.
- Anthony O. from West Allis, Wisconsin
This Lake Is A No Go. Dont Waste Your Time Coming Here. To Many Skiers And Tubers.
- Fishingnutt from Waukesha, Wi
Have Really Enjoyed This Lake. Walleyes And Smallies Abundant With Occasional Carp Or Gar
- Gary from Delafield,Wi
This Is An Awesome Lake To Boat And Tub, Very Family Friendly!!
- Abby And Kristin from Nashotah, Wi
This Lake Is The Best For Tubing!
- George from Madison, Wi
Try The Kettle In About 30 Feet Of Water For Suspended Gills. (north End Of Nagiwicka)
- Vince from Genesee
Big Lake, Moblity Is Key. Plan On Drilling Lots Of Holes To Find A Fish.
- Aaron from Nashotah
Good Size Pans Northerns,walleye,largemouth And Smallies Abundunt,great Lake
- Carl from Milwaukee
Fish Are SMALL...WAY Too Many Rude Skiers And Tubers. More Productive During Early Morning Or Night
- Ron from Waukesha Wi
Good Lake, 22 Inches Largemouth Bass
- Joe Cardenas from East Troy Wisconsin
Good Tip Up Fishing, 26 In. Northerns
- Pat Murack from Waukesha Wi
This Is An Over All Good Fishing Lake!
- Bassman from Oconomowoc