There are currently 3 reviews for Horsehead Lake.
Lots of perch but haven't found them over 8". Haven't fished the entire lake, but less cabbage beds than most lakes, although one decent one on east side with a few crappies. Reports of walleyes near the rocks jutting out from the point opposite the landing, but not for me so far. But do watch out for those rocks, they come out a long ways, and very close to surface.
- Norman Kedrowski from Stevens Point, WI
Only detectable fish are small perch (in the thousands) and the apex predator Muskie. Muskies seem to have taken out all middle predator game fish as well as pan fish of decent size.
- luke steele from sheboygan
Slow fishing overall, better choices in the area.
- stuart smith from DeForest, Wisconsin