There are currently 13 reviews for Castle Rock Lake.
The lake has always had wind erosion to contend with. Now there is extensive boat traffic that is causing extensive erosion of unprotected shores which fills in the deeper holes. Along with modern technologies and winter draw downs are decimating the sport fish populations. IMHO. Joe Due
- joseph due from mauston
This lake is a proven producer for big pan fish! I have caught just about every species of fish on this big brown lake! I even caught a five pound catfish on my jig pole through the ice one year! If you haven't fished this lake in the winter, be cautious. The ice can be "tricky"! Plus it is almost always windy! We have had to chase buckets and shacks across the ice! Good luck!
- Jeremy Hisel from LaValle
I've fished this lake for 35 years. The fishing is getting progressively worse (walleyes, crappies, bluegills and smallmouth)with all the shoreline development,heavy fishing pressure and the overpopulation of white bass and sheepshead. It's a real shame. This lake used to be one of the best.
- Dennis W Dodge from New Lisbon
Water was really really brown because of the rain but fish were hitting in shallower water on minnows. Great lake to fish
- homer arndt from hillsboro, Wisconsin
Last summer took the whole family here and had great success in the middle of summer. Caught about anything just fishing the bottom w/ nightcrawlers. Many white bass 3lb and bigger. Going back this year in a couple of weeks.
- SHANNON STEPHENSON from BRADLEY, Illinois
great for crappie.set out a couple of flags with medium shiners if your timing is right you will have a good day
- marty hagan from new lisbon, Wisconsin
the fish here are few but they are big , well worth your time
- matt stout from reedsburg, Wisconsin
i have fished this lake for 35 years, and the walleye are making a come back. Small mouth and pike are good also.pan fish always good. i would recomend you try it. i'll be back up in March.
- Robert Rains from peotone, Illinois
Castle rock lake has been a wonderful place for walleyes. I caught a 4.5 pond walleye, on a floating jig (green). so keep on trying there are big fish in that lake.
- Stephen T. from milwaukee, Wisconsin
Caught some monster smallmouth bass on the main lake. The backwaters are weedy and never hold fish. I really like the walleye fishing that this lake offers.
- Jeff Buckingham from Hebron, Wisconsin
Fished castle rock lake for first time 24 jun 2001. Lake and surrounding area is beautiful.
- Kevin Lones from Sycamore, Illinois
Fantastic Lake With A Variety Of Hotspots: Rivers, Bridges, Dams, Man-Made Islands, Etc. Fantastic!
- Jeff Kline from Green Bay, Wi
Trophy Crappies,outstanding Panfish, Abundance Of Eyes And Future Trophy Northerns
- Hyper 1(jerry Pierce) from Monee,il