Pony Creek Tustin Lake Poygan

Displaying 1 to 10 of 64 Posts
5/3/18 @ 5:42 AM
peanut09
peanut09
USER since 1/17/10

Any crappie in there yet? It should be soon.

Post Your Comment
4/11/18 @ 8:43 PM
Carpio
Carpio
MEMBER since 11/5/17

A day late and a dollar short! The story of my life lol. Yes , the west side appeared to be 2-3 ft. Deep but the east side has a mud flat almost blocking the creek. Some of the other southern channels were 1/2 froze. Poygan has a lot of ice ( bad) on it.   I saw one crappie caught in one hr.  2 weeks till the crappies come in unless the water drops and blocks the entrance. I’ve never seen that but it’s possible.   Good fishin!  CARPIO

Post Your Comment
4/11/18 @ 7:29 PM
carnsteve
carnsteve
USER since 1/23/09

It’s deeper than that in the park. I did very well on Saturday. Only kept the ones over 10”.

Pony Creek Tustin Lake Poygan Photo
Post Your Comment
4/11/18 @ 2:28 PM
Carpio
Carpio
MEMBER since 11/5/17

Just returned from pony creek. Didn’t even wet a line. 50-60 people keeping 6-7” perch and a 10” Walleye! What a joke. This is on a week day! Winneconne just about blocked off , road closed signs everywhere. Nobody fishing at omro. The spot under the bridge for white bass was Dry!  Pony creek itself only 6” deep. Poygan waaaay low. Didn’t go to Fremont.  CARPIO 

Post Your Comment
4/3/18 @ 2:19 PM
krusen_for_carp
krusen_for_carp
USER since 10/7/16

after this cold i doubt theyre still in there

Post Your Comment
4/3/18 @ 2:09 PM
rather B fishn.
rather B fishn.
USER since 1/12/18

The Smalleys went back in the creek.

Post Your Comment
4/3/18 @ 2:08 PM
rather B fishn.
rather B fishn.
USER since 1/12/18

 Went and gave it a try came back with four keepers and nine Smalleys 

Post Your Comment
4/3/18 @ 8:07 AM
FISHING REPORT
Swept away
Swept away
USER since 1/3/13

MOON PHASE (89%)
Waning Gibbous

Perch bite is on. Some small ones but you can weed thru them and come home with a nice meal. Minnows working best or minnow pieces. Water very low but they are there.

Post Your Comment
1/22/18 @ 3:56 AM
FISHING REPORT
The Phantom
The Phantom
USER since 7/16/12

MOON PHASE (28%)
Waxing Crescent

We did pretty good down there. Just follow that Gary guy and ask him

Post Your Comment
1/1/18 @ 3:59 PM
bigfishwisco
bigfishwisco
USER since 12/29/17

Its real slow if u catch any they are real small.i fished there yesterday 10 am till 4 pm cought 2 fish.a dink perch an a tiny lm bass

Post Your Comment
Displaying 1 to 10 of 64 Posts