Softplastic... It's been a few years since I've fished Jordan, I've never had any luck there when targeting pan fish on the ice. To find northerns and LMB, find the shelf off the west side of the north point. Set tip-ups ranging from 3' - 8' FOW. I like to use medium shiners and a flashy spoon to add some extra attraction. I used to catch a lot of hammer handles in that area, and would occasionally pull out a 30"+ northern. I've also caught several 3-4 lb LMB out of that area on tip-ups.
Moving a little further west, almost halfway between the point and the boat launch, there used to be a fish crib (not sure if it's still there), where you could find some nice perch. I used to use a tip-up with a single hook and a crappie minnow in about 4-6 feet of water.
Hope that helps!