There are currently 11 reviews for Palmer Lake.
Click here to add your personal review of Palmer Lake.
Scott Wilsmann from Mishicot, Wisconsin(7/20/06)
"Very low visability. Caught several small perch and walleye. Fished one day for Muskie but unsuccessful. A good lake to skip over on your way to Tenderfoot!"
Tim Culver from Sussex, Wisconsin(4/8/05)
"Wow, I don't know how many people are being "fooled"? Tried some late season ice fishing, 18 snowmobiles, 26 four wheelers on the lake by 10am, probably around 100 people fishing. Never seen so much fishing pressure on a Vilas County Lake. Sure hope this lake stays a secret??? I'll try back on a week day."
brandon osimitz from lodi, Wisconsin(5/27/04)
"fished this lake a few years ago. my partner and i boated 5 monster muskies in a weeks worth of fishing. all caught and released. heading up there this weekend."
One More Cast from Up North, Wisconsin(2/21/02)
"This lake has always been known for muskie as the "first legal" lake-lots of fish where you can catch a legal size fish, but without trophy potential. Lots of action, very scenic. Have caught nice largemouth on muskie lures too. Campsites on shore. Trip to Tenderfoot on the Ontanongan R. is fun, but watch for rock hazards!! Giant crappies have been caught (18") on Tenderfoot."
Orv Smuttle from West Bend, Wisconsin(8/29/01)
"Great atmosphere, great lake for that getaway! Dark water & weeds makes it easy to catch fish anytime!"
BIG Fish from Milwaukee, Wisconsin(8/22/01)
"Great day of fishing - Few Boats - don't let the locals fool ya on passing over this one!"
John Heibler from Germantown, Wisconsin(7/25/01)
"Toooooo many people fish this lake.....weekends?....forget it!
Opening weekend this year?.....10 rigs in the parking lot....THE NIGHT BEFORE! Some CAMPING!
Mr jacklin is right..too much pressure means too few larger fish."
Neighbors from Milwaukee(9/27/00)
"Good Lake, Lots Of Lake Owners Talk It Down To Keep It Secret - Don´t Pass It Over"
Brian Jacklin from Slinger, Wi(6/27/00)
"Definetely Not A Trophy Muskie Lake. Lots Of Pressure, Very Few Large Fish."
Jeff O. from Appleton, Wi(5/31/00)
"I Guided Some Friends To A Great Weekend Of Walleye Fishing. Good Time By All!"
Brian Karthauser from Mequon Wisconsin(6/2/99)
"Bring Your Weedless Tackle Along, This Is A Lake Where Anywhere Is Good Fishin!"