I'm not disagreeing with you Skeeter, but most guides i know don't keep their limit to give away to the client. If they do, they don't give it to the 2nd group as well. most don't walk those lines typically, they have much more to lose.. Do guides play a role in taking fish, sure. Many are to blame, not only guides. Larry Smith has said for YEARS he doesn't like the no size limit on bago. He's a huge advocate for throwing back spawners as well as most guides.
Only those people know if they play part in the glutton
I'm with you though, as one guy said on here prior, catch many, take few. I like that.
Now the guys from Milwaukee that come up to fish 4 times a year, those are the ones I feel for. Drive 1.5 hours to keep 3 walleyes. The out of towners are the ones that will feel the 3 fish limit the most. The locals with get theirs regardless of it's 3 or 5.
I suppose it's not different that northen WI, they have lower bags as well.