Fishing reports and lake information for Minnesota, Michigan, Wisconsin, Illinois, Ohio, Indiana, North Dakota and South Dakota

Ice Fishing for Carp

Sort posts by date: Descending Ascending

Original Post:

Shake-N-Bake
Shake-N-Bake
Level: General User
Joined: 3/9/2009
Status: Offline
2/15/10 5:41 PM CST
Does anybody try this. If so wondering what you were using for bait?

1234567890
See Profile
Profile
Level: General User
Joined: 10/5/2005
Status: Offline
2/16/10 5:40 PM CST
can anybody sum up ajs's post? I'm too lazy to read that much.

If you keep your ears open you might be surprised how often people catch carp through the ice. I've been hearing a bit this winter about people jigging for walleyes on the wolf river and getting multiple carp on jig and minnow or swedish pimples. I'm sure if you were to fine tune that and try a little harder you could do decent on any any river.

catalale
catalale
Level: General User
Joined: 9/22/2009
Status: Offline
2/16/10 4:23 PM CST
I would try anwhere from corn to worms and minnows. Try chumming with creamed corn and corn flakes and make a "ball" out of the mixture and drop it down. We do this in the summer.

rockbassman33
rockbassman33
Level: General User
Joined: 1/11/2008
Status: Offline
2/16/10 8:54 AM CST
I often carp fish in the spring in some ponds near my house as practice for fighting large smallies when I go up north but it never really occurred that it was possible to get them through the ice. I always assumed they were much more lethargic and in a sort of hibernation. Now I'll have to take a shot at it sometime!

fishermandan
See Profile
Profile
Level: General User
Joined: 7/21/2002
Status: Offline
2/16/10 8:51 AM CST
I went carp jigging for the first time last Sunday, it was definitely something new. The key was to find large schools cruising along a shallow breakline. When they came through, my humminbird was red from top to bottom! The gear was a medium heavy jig rod spooled with 14lb fireline, and we were using a top secret variety of artificial lures. By the end, we landed 17 carp from 8-14lbs. Once we were done, we tossed them in my buddy's field for fertilizer. The guy I went with has had days where they landed 50 or more up to 25lbs.

SHAKE N' BAKE
SHAKE N' BAKE
Level: General User
Joined: 3/27/2008
Status: Offline
2/15/10 11:01 PM CST
Get a new handle i was here first! Evil Grin

Pete Pete Pete
Pete Pete Pete
Level: General User
Joined: 12/21/2005
Status: Offline
2/15/10 9:45 PM CST
This is great. We've been discussing doing this for years now. No shame whatsoever in fighting these brutes.

ajs
See Profile
Profile
Level: General User
Joined: 12/19/2001
Status: Offline
2/15/10 6:23 PM CST

Here,s a post from another site on the subject.

Ajs

You’re Catching WHAT!?! Late Ice Carp Tactics ….Yeah Really!!

Everyone has found themselves carp fishing at some time or another. And although most people don’t really pursue them too actively, or even admit that they liked catching them, they sure can put up a fight. Ask anyone who has tied into one while crappie fishing with light tackle, you had better have a good drag or they will put a bruising on your equipment. I have always been a sucker for just about anything that will tug at the other end of the line. On days when I couldn’t get on the water I have even been known to play tug-o-war with my dog by tying one of her chew toys to the end of my musky rod (yeah, I have a problem). So when my brother and I found ourselves trying to sight fish shallow gills this past February and all we kept seeing when looking down the holes were huge carp, we knew precisely what needed to be done. Luckily I had left a couple of tip-ups in my truck from a previous outing.

Lacking traditional carp gear (although I am not sure what technically constitutes traditional carp gear, nor does anyone else on this side of the Atlantic ocean); we took a couple of tip-ups and improvised. All my tip-ups were pre-rigged with 50 lb Power Pro line, but this being gin-clear water we added a Spro swivel and 6-7 feet of 20 lb fluorocarbon to the end of each. My brother added a size 6 circle hook to his with no weight and baited it with as many wax worms as he could squeeze onto it. I took a slightly different approach. Some of the fish were cruising and from the looks of it they were picking off aquatic insects as they swam around. So I took a size 12 Lindy Genz Bug and loaded it with waxies. It didn’t take more than 5 minutes before a flag was flying. The first fish came on my brothers circle hook rig, and he made the mistake of taking his gloves off before trying to land the fish. Well that first fish gave him several line burns on his fingers to make him think better of taking his gloves off the next time. It also weighed in at only 4 lbs on his digital scale, and man was I excited to see what one of the bigger ones we had seen swimming around could do.

The commotion from the fish (and my brother’s squeals of pain as he got burned from the line) attracted some attention from a group of people crappie fishing not too far from where we were. Two of them came over to talk to us about what we were catching, and thought we were either stupid for fishing for carp, or lying through our teeth and had found either some big northerns or walleyes in the shallows (supposed "real fish"). Luckily they didn’t have to wait around long to see it with their own eyes as my brother’s tip-up went off again. This time he left his gloves on, and when the slush cleared and we managed to squeeze it up the hole we has holding a beautiful (they say beauty is in the eye of the beholder) 7lb carp. By the end of the day we were able to ice 6 beautiful (c’mon, they are cooler looking than walleyes) carp, the biggest being a 10 lb brute that took a little extra effort to squeeze up the hole. All while catching bluegills not 50 yards away.

Now We’re Prepared, Whatever That Means

We decided to be a little more prepared the next time we went out to that spot. This was going to be a serious attempt at fishing for only carp. We even took the time to make dough balls out of Wheaties and vanilla extract, which have always been a killer for us when open water carp fishing. The fishing really seemed to pick up from the previous day, or maybe it was just because we were “serious carp fisherman” now. Try calling yourself that without laughing. The action was split between dough balls on the bottom and wax worms about 1 foot off of the bottom, and we ended up icing around 15 fish, although it did seem as though our bigger fish were caught on dough balls lying on the bottom. I also decided it would be a good idea to rig up a tip-down, which is like a tip up except it allows you to fight the fish with a rod and reel. My reasoning was that it would be a lot more fun to fight the fish on a rod and reel, and it would help me avoid burns from the line and the girlish squealing that would ensue. The one down-side to the tip-down is that the moment the fish felt any resistance they would drop the bait, so I had to open the bail and just constantly check to see if I had a fish. Luckily we were using circle hooks so I didn’t have to worry about gut hooking any of these gorgeous fish (they really aren’t that ugly)

We took a look around the area in between flags and found out a little more about the area we were catching these fish. We were getting the majority of our fish in 9-10 feet of water over a sandy/weedy bottom at the entrance to a small bay. This particular area came up out of a 22 foot mud flat very quickly. The back of the bay was very muddy and had a stream that connected to several other lakes. Although we never checked the temp of the water we figured that was a big reason why the fish were in that area, as well as the bug hatches that we could see coming up our holes.

As the snow cover began to diminish near the end of this ice season we found that the fish became a lot spookier and would take longer to move back into an area after we had drilled holes. They also began to move back further into the bay over the dark bottomed areas. They were still biting, but if there was any commotion going on above them they would vacate the area, so there have been fewer doubles on the tip-ups.

Why? Because They are Fish!

I have received almost the same reaction out of everyone I have told about this bite so far, “Why?” And all I can really say in response is that you have to try it, if for no other reason than it gives you an excuse to still have a tip-up out while you are out fishing for panfish. So dust off those tip-ups, grab yourself a pack of circle hooks and some canned corn or dough balls and make an excuse to fish carp for a day, or don’t tell anyone if you feel embarrassed. This is one fish that will quickly win you over, if not for its looks (although I still say they are way better looking than walleyes), than for its sheer brute strength and willingness to eat almost anything. Hook up with a carp on a tip-up (but leave your gloves on) and try and wipe the smile off of your face, I dare you.

Launch Map Viewer


Remember Me
Setup New Account
Forgot Your Password?
Membership Benefits
Compare Account Types
Please Practice Catch And Release
Lake-Link asks you to please take a moment to visit our fine sponsors:
Custom Jigs & Spins Plano Frabill Chevy Dealers Of Wisconsin Humminbird St. Croix Rods The 60 Second Angler Jerry's Sport Service Midwestern Shooters Supply Hard And Soft Fishing Fenwick HT Plano

Lake-Link.com find us on facebook