Snowmobile vs. ATV

1/17/11 @ 7:58 PM
ORIGINAL POST
the walleye guy
the walleye guy
USER since 5/3/09
I am toying with the idea of buying either a snowmobile or an ATV. I live in south-central wisconsin where there are no ATV trails around, although i live in the country with a lot of cornfields around that the owners don't care if i ride on. The problem that i have with that is that crops are up in the summer and by the time theyre off, hunting season is here. I also don't really have the means to go up north to trails on a regular basis. There are snowmobile trails around though and of course there are no crops up in the winter to stop me from riding on the same cornfields i mentioned. But the season for snowmobiling is much shorter and the trails may not be open very long. If you were in my situation which would you buy? Im on a low budget since im a high schooler, but really would like a toy and something to drag an ice shack.

Post Your Comment
Displaying 1 to 10 of 16 Posts
6/25/11 @ 12:54 PM
Dbrockman
Dbrockman
USER since 2/23/11
this is a beautiful thing

paid 1500 with 4500 miles

Post Your Comment
5/14/11 @ 10:55 PM
cookiedough
cookiedough
USER since 5/1/11
depends, do you like the winter and can stand the cold, get a snowmobile especially since you are near snowmobile trails and no ATV trails nearby. A good used snowmobile can be had easily for 2-3 grand where as a good used ATV will run 3-4 grand. Buy whatever you will use the most and enjoy. For me, there are tons of more snowmobile trails around here, but with the winters so short and it always seems the timing is not right to drive a snowmobile with other things going on like work and family, etc. Also, not an expert, but snowmobiles are not as reliable and can break down easier (in general) and be more expensive to repair and own than an ATV can be. I have a 2000 and 2003 ATV and besides regular oil changes, nothing has really gone wrong with them both besides 2 minor repairs (oil cooler lines leaking and new brake pads) on my 2003 polaris ATV. I find usually an older snowmobile for sale has more problems than an older ATV and usually the snowmobile has many more miles on them. There are tons of good used ATV's to be had out there that are not beat up with very low miles not being used vs. good used low mileage not beat up snowmobiles. For ice fishing pulling a shack, go for the ATV since unless over 12" of snow on the ice, I have never gotten stuck with my ATV on the ice, just make sure you get 4wd.

Edited on 5/14/11 10:56 PM
Post Your Comment
5/9/11 @ 8:15 PM
walleye-master
walleye-master
USER since 2/28/08
4x4 ATV

Post Your Comment
5/9/11 @ 7:24 PM
garyq
garyq
MEMBER since 4/1/10
I am as well looking for an ATV just to pull my stuff out on ice any advice on size ice 200 CC's vs 400 CCs or 4 x 4 or 2 x 2's. Would not get a snowmobile so we need to go for the quad as I am a bigger guy 5'11" and 300 lbs and a 3 wheeler is not for me

There is a reason why they no longer can make them. And too small for a big guy like me

Any ideas or suggestions would be welcome. I have heard about the 4x4's would be the only way to go but have now heard about many saying that the 2x2 is also easily work.

Post Your Comment
3/22/11 @ 11:56 AM
cds
cds
USER since 9/18/01
For icefishing,if there's no snow,walking's easy. If there's a lot of snow,many ATVs get stuck.

'Round here,there's alot of lakes where no sleds or ATVs are allowed. Guys with machines don't fish them as much because it's not convenient or easy to get around. When there's no snow on the ice,I fish those lakes.

When there's a lot of snow,I'm not going to pull all that crap: A sled is then the way to go.

In addition,there's a couple lakes in my area where the access doesn't allow the operation of an ATV or snowmobile (or trailer parking) but they are allowed on the lake. In those cases,my little Honda 110 ATC can be unloaded from my truck,pushed to the ice,THEN used on the lake in full compliance of the law.

Cost of a sled vs ATV - and be wary of a cheap ATV....A decent,working 3-wheeler can be had pretty cheaply. Most were beat,some weren't. Mine wasn't....Parts are still available...But there's a reason they're no longer made.

Post Your Comment
3/18/11 @ 4:57 PM
Dbrockman
Dbrockman
USER since 2/23/11
i like sleds. if u use them they are worth having. i put on 1200 miles this year so to mr it is worth it. sleds arent made to be useful either, they r made for fun. atvs are nice in the summer, but how many miles do u actually put on them compared to a snowmobile. they arent really that good in the snow anyhow. the only time i use it in the winter is to plow the driveway. just my opinion

Post Your Comment
1/21/11 @ 4:40 PM
Tired & Retired
Tired & Retired
USER since 2/21/05
I also have both, 2 snowmobiles & 3 atv's & I would recommend the atv. Its a year around machine whenever u get a chance to use it . Snowmobiles are limited to weather conditions & a short season at that. Atv's can also be useful around the yard (plowing, & carts for hauling or even grass cutting if property is large enough.) We pull sledders & skiers behind the atv in winter also, & to pull our ice shelter out on the lake.

Post Your Comment
1/19/11 @ 7:44 AM
Steve H
Steve H
MEMBER since 8/20/01
I have had both and much prefer the ATV. However I agree that you can pick up a decent snowmobile for under $1,000 and probably an ATV in that price range would be junk.

Post Your Comment
1/18/11 @ 12:56 PM
quacksmacker88
quacksmacker88
USER since 11/12/10
sleds tend to be alot cheaper, i paid $400 for mine and have put on 5,000 miles without any problems

Edited on 1/18/11 12:57 PM
Post Your Comment
1/18/11 @ 10:53 AM
Metzie
Metzie
USER since 3/22/07
ATV all the way. 12 month vs 1-3 if you are lucky. I am handicap so I use mine every day. Just go for a ride, feed chickens and birds, go to mailbox, snowplow,hunting & ice fishing, yard work, trail riding and tons of other things. I couldn't live with out it. If you can afford it get one with four wheel drive and a winch. Smile

Post Your Comment
Displaying 1 to 10 of 16 Posts